Sunday, September 10, 2023

Displaced Faith or Misplaced Faith? (#5 in Series - False Allegations)

 

“Thou Shall Not Bear False Witness”

I dedicate this section to the tzadikim, I know you are out there.  I pray for you.  You are not forgotten in this mess.

There is a Hebrew story told by a holy rabbi that at any given point in the world there exists 36 Tzadikim, or righteous ones, and if even one of them were missing, the world would come to an end.  Amen.  Amen.

It was a face I never expected to see on the front cover of the newspaper.  A face of a man who had been dragged out of his rectory-home in the middle of the night by the police and hauled down to the station for “processing.”  His picture looks like they roughed-him-up.  He appeared quite distressed.  I read the article and shook my head sideways – this cannot be.  And so I wrote to the journalist, “You are guilty of Trial-by-Media.  Every man is due his day in court.  In THIS COUNTRY people are ‘innocent until proven guilty.’”  She wrote back to me, “Is there something I should know?”  At that point, my beloved little Catholic mother would not have approved of what I muttered underneath my breath.

Be clear about this:  Media exists to Sell media.  Good news isn’t particularly interesting.  Something very base in the human person feeds on the details of the grime of life.  It is that grist that sells newspapers, magazines, movies, etc.  If this were not so, how does the National Enquirer still exist?  We all know it’s a load of hooey.  And yet people pay good money to read it.  Baffling.  Look at what people are watching on tv:  very little graphic injury, violent murder, appalling crime scene is left to the imagination.  People pay for cable TV and streaming all of this junk often over a hundred dollars a month per household.  So, in all points, we have to keep foremost in our minds:  Follow the Money.  Where the money is, the story will be.  Even if the story is just an allegation.  Even if it is not true.

And perhaps you are wondering how I responded to her… what I said was along these lines: “The man that has been accused is a man I have spoken to personally in the privacy of my own confession.  He is good.  He is virtuous.  He is also admittedly handsome, and with little imagination I could see where a single mother with kids would be attracted to his grounded-ness and make a pass at him.  (I was hypothesizing, I had no information.  Genesis 39:7-20 tells a similar story).  If he refused, she could destroy him with an allegation because the reality is, a real predator would be less likely to abuse children in the same family because one weak link could spill the beans.  The story doesn’t make sense.  It is not in keeping with the person I have always seen him to be.” 

Weeks later on the inside of the newspaper in a tiny corner was a very short statement saying he had been acquitted.  Unfortunately, the damage had been done.  His reputation was destroyed and he disappeared.  To this day, his name remains on the 2018 List of Those Credibly Accused.  It should not be.  The people who wrote in to the letters to the editor had shredded him up in a million pieces how could he stay in the local community and re-integrate in any way when his name had been utterly demolished?

So, here we are in 2023, a couple of weeks after the big announcement about Justice Payments to Victims and yet another allegation comes out.  My, what impeccable timing.  Get it in quickly, just to be sure you get your million. 

A local godly pastor said words to this effect about this recent allegation:  “The Father XYZ that worked with us has not shown himself to be inappropriate in any way.  That is not the Father XYZ that I have known.”  I am grateful the pastor said that much.  Many would have left those words UNSAID, which would only build the suspicions in the minds of the people.  Also, I imagine that the Good Priests walk a very careful path to avoid saying anything that may support someone who is justifiably accused.

But the Bad News didn’t stop there.  The mother and young woman have offered details of the incidents to the newspaper … which were printed.  “Nice job.”  It really is the only way you can nail a lid into a proverbial coffin with no real concrete evidence:  build an image in the public’s mind that paints a person guilty by way of the appallingly graphic details that would outrage anyone. 

Now I ask you, gentle reader, do you, like me, find it difficult to un-read graphic allegations in the light of proven innocence later on? 

And where was this girl’s father when this was going on?  Why is he silent?  Why did it take so many years for this girl to come forth and, “oh, by the way Mom …”  How old was she when she was texting with him?  Is there a record of those texts as proof? 

I ask these questions to enlarge the scope of what we are looking at.  Frankly, in this case as well, I find it all unbelievable.  If for some reason this is a valid accusation of yet another Bad Actor, I think we are so far away from stopping this mess we need another alternative.  Putting the entire laity through the “Safe Environment” courses is not working.  Offering Justice Payments and bankrupting every single church in the diocese is not the answer.  Why the employer of clergy has to take on the lawsuits at all is kind of confusing to me.  But maybe I’m just not that smart.  If I worked for a regular company and made inappropriate and unwelcome advances, I would be summarily fired.  That would be that.  Any lawsuits would be aimed at the offender, not the employer. 

By the way, Safe Environment training does not work.  Oh, oops, did I say that out loud?  Yikes.  A story … from a land far away … quite a long time ago …

I popped in to the parish dance to see how things were going.  There was a handwritten sign on the entrance door stating, “Authorized Personnel Only beyond this point” or some such thing.  It was put in place by the lay volunteer who was running the dance.  I walked in the door and was questioned – and had to pull rank and say, “I am on Parish STAFF, I am definitely Authorized.”  Good heavens, save us.  But apparently the person running the show didn’t look too carefully at the parent chaperone sitting at the door, or smell what was actually in his coffee cup.  Meanwhile inside the dance, the caterer who was an elderly woman was out on the dance floor with the junior high kids, particularly, the boys.  I walked up to another staff member and stood shoulder to shoulder.  I tilted my head to the side and commented, “Um, yeah, I would keep an eye on THAT situation…” and I walked out the door.  She verbally dismissed my concerns.  My post-event chat with the pastor the next morning confirmed my suspicions that things were managed poorly and there had been some fallout.  In Polish we have a saying, “Nie moj cyrk; nie moje malpy.”  I think that people, to some degree, only see what they want to see.  I have said since then to other youth ministers and catechists, “If something feels weird to you, it probably is.  Take the second glance.  Trust your gut.” 

I need to wrap this up.  Enough has been said at this point.  Except for this.  This morning my mind stirred up thoughts of the writings of the early American pastor Jonathan Edwards.  He was famous for writing a piece called “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.”  He paints a portrait of the sinner, like a spider, hanging on a thread over the mouth of a cavernous hell.  (Much like I picture the predators to be.)

While on the one hand he implores, “And now you have an extraordinary opportunity, a day wherein Christ has thrown the door of mercy wide open, and stands in calling and crying with a loud voice to poor sinners…” he wraps his sermon up with, “Therefore, let everyone that is out of Christ, now awake and fly from the wrath to come.  The wrath of Almighty God is now undoubtedly hanging over a great part of this congregation:  let everyone fly out of Sodom.”

Pray for your pastors.  Pray for the leadership.  Pray for our children.  And pray for those who bear false witness, their judgment, I imagine, shall be harsh for they destroy the name of a good man and the peace of the community. 

“For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ so that each may receive his due for what he has done … the good and the bad.”  (2 Corinthians 5:10).

The ridiculousness of this entire situation cannot continue.  It must not.   So help us, God.

###########

 


Displaced Faith or Misplaced Faith? (#4 in Series - Money)

 

The Truth About Money

You do not have to even take your shoes off to feel it.  The ground beneath us is rumbling.  It is a shaking from the bodies of immigrant Catholic grand and great-grandparents of this and other Diocese(s) rolling in their graves.  And I don’t blame them one bit.  They came to this country in many cases with barely the clothes on their backs.  They worked in factories and on the farms for days on end and hours more than 40 a week to build a new life here that mattered, that had dignity, honor, meaning, and sanctity.  They sweat and sacrificed to establish homes, families, and churches.  They treated their pastors like princes on pedestals for the role they were to serve in the faith community.  Often they sacrificed the luxuries of life so that the church, too, would have a bright future with a “nest egg” being set aside for days to come.

And here it is that very money, donated and saved at quite a personal cost – in some cases akin to the Biblical story of the Widow’s Mite – is being laid out in extravagant amounts to do WHAT?

I know you too are asking this question:  WHY such huge, pre-emptive, it seems, pay-outs relative to the diocesan scandals?  Before I attempt to reason an answer to that seemingly rhetorical question, I will say what the money WILL NOT, indeed cannot do:

1)      Money will not restore lost innocence to the victims.  There is no applicable price tag on the sexual, spiritual, physical, and emotional health of the human person. 

2)      Money will not adequately compensate:

a.       A child for his/her victimization

b.       A family for its heartache

c.       A psychologist for having to help unwind the emotional mess, should a person be brave enough to seek counseling

3)      And Money certainly won’t relieve a predator and his allies from culpability and guilt.

4)      Money cannot serve as a retroactive “evangelization tool.”  No one who left the Church because of this morally outrageous situation will return to it because the Institutional Church somehow miraculously appears generous by giving out money.  That ship has sailed.

A   And for those who still find it in their hearts to gather with faithful people to pray on a weekly basis, the money/pay-out seems just one big confusing and outrageous decision … made by many bishops across the country in response to litigation and fears thereof.  Tell us it won’t come from Sunday collections, as if that makes it all good.  You are decisively robbing our grandparents and expecting us to be okay with that.

As I slip my gypsy turban on and take out my proverbial crystal ball, I will tell you the future:

A)      We already know these scandals have bankrupted the diocese across the USA.  No news there, but wait …

B)      Now this leeching of money from the individual parishes will weaken each parish’s ability to function … and survive.

C)      The responsibility will roll to “we the people” to do all the raffles, bake sales, spaghetti dinners ad nauseum to keep our parishes in the black financially.  We don’t mind supporting our parishes, but we DO very much mind cleaning up someone else’s MESS from a systemic failure of oversight and accountability.

I find it disgustingly ironic that the first area of ministry to suffer in the wake of the scandals is actually YOUTH MINISTRY.  For example, the Faith centers closed.  Or was that because they were ministering to high school students in neighborhood-based centers as stand-alone ministries that helped kids but didn’t always “feed” bodies and envelope dollars back into local parishes.  It’s all about the kids, until it’s not.

Weekend retreats, where we the laity did our best work with teens, were cut down to day-only events.  Retreat centers closed.  Pastors that didn’t know what a good youth minister did wouldn’t even pay a living wage to get it started back then.  Few want to touch youth ministry with a ten-foot pole as it is.  I want to acknowledge that the GOOD priests are suffering, and probably afraid to be falsely accused (which has happened at least three times now that I am aware of).  And yet the online newspaper doesn’t update the 2018 List of those with Credible Allegations in order to restore the reputations of those falsely accused.  Newspapers, in whatever format, exist to sell news.  Bad news sells.  Restoration of dignity gets lower left corner of page 4, three sentences.

Oh, and lastly,

D)      If you think we’ve seen a vocational crisis in the past 20 years, you haven’t seen anything yet, baby I tell you.  The only three things I recall during my lifetime that generate strong vocations to the priesthood were:  (1) the youth conferences at Steubenville; (2) adoration of the Blessed Sacrament in parishes; and (3) the entire papacy of Saint Pope John Paul the Great as he reached out to the youth of the world with clarity and relevance, inviting them to throw open wide the doors to Christ.  If we lose the ability to reach our youth with Biblical relevance and pure faith, the whole thing is going to go belly-up. 

 ######################

 

Displaced Faith or Misplaced Faith? (#3 in Series - Institutionalism)

 

An Unsinkable Ship?

You will not be likely to ever see me on a cruise ship.  Every time someone mentions it, my mind veers back to the phrase that was declared about the Titanic, “Even GOD couldn’t sink this ship.”  Need I say more?  Over-confidence in the designs of man paves a path to destruction.  The tower of Babel was also such an icon of man’s pride which ended up utterly destroyed.  (Genesis 11)

So is this Ship of the Institutional Catholic Church what the Lord was talking about when He said to Peter that the gates of hell itself would not prevail against it … This Church with too many really human beings in it… the good, the bad, the ugly?  That is a question that Practical Me asks Theological Me a lot lately. 

Before my contemporary theologian friends begin to argue the point, hear me out.  The Lord intends that His Bride, the Church, will be standing holy and spotless before Him on the last day.  This institutional thing that is bellowing and belching at the seams as it chugs along is not that Bride.  It can’t be. 

I don’t just propose, but I am actually saying:  If you put your faith in an Institution, no matter how well-intentioned, you are going to be disappointed.  The Clergy Scandals are clear evidence of that.  And even as I pound this out on my keyboard, the bishops meet in Germany to discuss whether or not certain moral behaviors are unacceptable in the eyes of the Church.  They must have misplaced their Bibles, and their brains.  Any change in moral code that goes against the clear teaching of the apostolic church and the people of God in Israel prior to that, is out of the question entirely.  Think about it.  IF … on the day that hell freezes over completely … IF the Catholic Church were to go ahead and sanction that behavior, then the seminaries will re-integrate with, you know, … and the predators of young boys will be back in the saddle again.  Beware, sheep.

Please.  Put your faith in the person of Christ.  In the God who is a Holy and Just God.  In the Spirit who brings about beautiful fruits in the lives of believers:  love, joy, peace, chastity, patience, kindness, gentleness, self-control.  (Galatians 5:22).  In God, you will not be disappointed.  Everything else gets put into perspective.  Clarity and Truth emerge.  Strength to walk a better path is given.  That’s what I’m saying.  The Hebrew Scriptures have a concept called “The Remnant,” which refers to a group of faithful people that God keeps close when all else is breaking loose.  When culture fails and religious establishment fails and the people of God are purified, He Himself is with the remnant in the fire.  (Daniel 3:24)

################

Displaced Faith or Misplaced Faith (#2 in Series)

 

Who Can Stand Before the Judgment Seat of God?  (Nahum 1:6)

That is a rhetorical question.  The answer is:  no one.  However, when it comes to sins, there are some things that are lesser, and there are some things that are greater.  And then there are some things that even a little bit is intolerable in the eyes of God or man.  In the natural world, the best example I can give you is seasoning food.  You can put a ¼ of a teaspoon of vanilla into a milkshake, or you can put a whole teaspoon and it will take a while before it is obviously way too much.  You can put a ¼ of a teaspoon of garlic into something and even more than that just makes you go, “bleck!  Too much garlic!”  Then there is GHOST PEPPER.  Last June, the waitress brought a tiny cup of ghost pepper to my friends at our table in a restaurant … wearing gloves.  She said, “Even if I get a bit of it on my fingertips and accidentally touch near my eye, I will be in a world of hurt.”  And then my buddy took a tiny bit in his mouth.  I have never seen a human being turn PURPLE before from a substance that miniscule.  And there you have it.

The scandals were erupting all around the country.  This priest.  That priest.  Bishops covering up.  Bishops declaring ignorance.  Bishops denouncing.  There were tales of cultural raunch that existed in a couple of seminaries.  It was like a lesson in Disgust.  Every story that came out was a little different; every story that came out was a little the same.  And we all wondered how many stories were left untold due to shame, fear, regret.  Or worse, how many adults were victimized as young people and are now scarred for life from the past and coping by substance abuse or ultimately committing suicide?  How could we abide all of this?  What the heck was happening?  How did the grooming-and-abusing process occur almost under our noses and we not see it for what it was?  And, for the love of heaven, How did an Institution that was created to be HOLY include and tolerate some leaders that were decisively, well, UN-HOLY PREDATORS?

Doing music ministry in parishes where the choir stands in front to the side of the altar has its advantages … and disadvantages.  Looking out in front of you are the smiling faces of fellow congregants praying, singing, listening, participating.  But then you, also, are in front of them so your reaction to any surprise is, well, right up front, literally.  Like the day that the Deacon of Disconnectedness stood in front of us and declared cheerfully and triumphantly, “The Church WILL survive this!”  I watched the question marks go across people’s faces as they processed that odd comment, even as I felt my own soul roar within me.  I was appalled that he would shift the focus from children who were abused to whether or not the Institution would make it.  He came up to me afterwards and shook my hand and thanked me for how well the song we played at the Offertory Procession “went with his homily,” which was, for my part, sheerly accidental.  He had misread me completely; I began to crunch his hand to lock him into the brief clarification we were about to have.  I said to him, “Actually I have a BEEF with your homily:  Nobody CARES about the Church right now.  Right now, we care about OUR KIDS.”  He looked baffled and walked away. 

The following week, our precious, godly pastor got up to the pulpit for his turn to weigh-in.  His religious order focuses on the theme “Make Me a Channel of Your Peace” for their way of life.  He told parents that because the topic he wanted to address was sensitive and “little pictures have big ears” he was going to use veiled language.  He explained that they should not be alarmed if they saw him wearing street clothes for a while instead of clerical garb when he is out in the community.  He felt just the sight of a man-in-black with a white collar was too much for some people.  Indeed, he had walked into a grocery store and saw a mother physically grab her youngster and pull the child towards herself while glaring at this priest. This is a guy who has the sweetest, kindest disposition.  If you knew him, you knew there was no malice in his heart towards children.  Then, to address the reality of the perpetrators, he held his left arm extended out from his side.  He declared, “I’ve got a solution:  I’ve got a rope and a tree.”  I guess the new theme would be, in this instance, “Make Me a Channel of Your Piece,” he was feeling the vibe of at least some of the people:  once the initial shock of what we are talking about tames down, you get just plain MAD.

I think Five Stages of Grief and Dying taught by Dr. Elisabeth Kubler-Ross apply handily to what we have walked through as a People.  The Denial process: “No.  This can’t be happening in our community.”  The Bargaining stage: “If we just put everyone through classes and pay money, this will all go away.”  The Depression: “This doesn’t seem to be dead quite yet.  Why the heck is that?!”  The Anger: “I’m mad as HELL and I’m not taking it anymore!”  The Resolution & Acceptance stage … um, I don’t think we are near there yet.  Probably because no one really knows exactly how to get there.

A few weeks ago, someone recommended I read EJ Fleming’s book Death of an Altar Boy.  I think that person did not realize I could write a book about some of MY experiences with the clergy.  I remember each of them by face and name:  The lewd comment to me and his snickering as one explained to his housekeeper, “I took a vow of celibacy, not chastity.”  Then there were the inappropriately-delivered hugs.  In one case, a college girl came to me and said, “Why do I feel so uncomfortable when he wants to hug me after Mass as I’m leaving the church?  He just pulls me right into his vestments and I want to pull away.”  I advised her just to exit via the other door and avoid the interaction.  (That was back in the day before the whistle blowing REALLY started.)  I have had more than one cleric personally deride me and/or my extensive educational experience, assessing me with a sneer as “so conservative”.  Then there was the misogynist who belittled every woman employee who walked into his office, to the point of making them cry, and two of them retired that year just to get that stress over with.  And these instances were not just one person; there were at least five+ that didn’t have “Gentleman” or “Respectful” as part of their character traits. 

Did they have people or parishioners who liked them as people?  Yes.  Of course.  Everyone has friends of some sort.  Did they help anyone or minister to anyone in their tenure as clergy?  I imagine so.  Two of them are no longer priests.  Yet there are also parishioners who, in the name of getting this process behind us, want to try and jettison through this uncomfortable purging stage and pretend it is not happening.  Perhaps those are the people who feel it’s someone else’s problem or do not know a victim personally … but I do.

I know of a young man who met an older gentleman (not clergy or church-related) with a PhD whom everyone just called, “The Doctor.”  The Doctor took this young man away on vacations.  He bought him a brand-new car for his high school graduation.  He showered him with presents.  The kid’s parents thought that he was a nice man who found their son as wonderful and worthy of good things as they did.  Mistake.  When something gets obviously excessive with gifts and trips, all the yellow and red lights should be flashing in the parents’ heads that says: “Grooming alert.  Grooming alert.  Predator in vicinity.”  The young man, after years of being abused and bribed to cover it up, finally came clean… and fell apart.  Then, after years of drug addiction, he took his own life.  I do not know where the “Doctor” is today.  But I hope he packed his marshmallows and a stick.  He’s going to need them.

“Jesus said unto them: ‘It would be better to be thrown into the sea with a millstone hung around your neck than to cause one of these little ones to fall into sin.”  (Luke 17:2)

So, in spite of my personal experiences, which I only hinted at here, I still read Death of an Altar Boy to learn more of the scope of the crisis because it happened in my home diocese of Springfield.  The one notorious cleric who so clearly had abused many young men, and most possibly murdered one of them, never served jail time.   According to the journalist’s research, the bungling of the evidence at the crime scene and disappearance of key items would have made for a difficult case “beyond reasonable doubt,” so he was a registered sex-offender on parole until he was 80.  Just when they were preparing to arrest him, he died of COVID.  To wit, there was implied connection between The Church, The Politicians, and The Law, in making sure this cleric did not have to face a murder conviction.

What I found most disturbing and curious about the book was the linking of adult males, clerical and non-clerical who seemed to have a ring of vice going in trafficking the young men.  How did this go undetected for so long?  For pages, Mr. Fleming named people and behaviors and events that the most genteel of readers would not be able to plow through.  It made me think of a conversation two or three guy friends at my college were having about their experiences in seminary back at the end of the 1970’s.  Both of them left the seminary due to the rampant sexually promiscuous behavior among the ranks.  Is it just me, or is it really very incongruous that someone would enter seminary to follow CHRIST and end up giving in to wholesale debauchery?  For this, there is no excuse.  And because of this, we are where we are as the Catholic Church.

“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven; but only those that do the will of my Father.”  (Matthew 7:21)

################################

Displaced Faith or Misplaced Faith? (#1 in Series)

 

Displaced Faith, or Misplaced Faith?  (Series on the Scandals in the Catholic Church)

(I hereby officially invoke my freedom of speech, my freedom of press, and my freedom in Christ.  Onward.)

Pre-amble

A few weeks ago in August, the pastors in our diocese were required to read a letter to their congregations at all weekend Masses announcing the intended settlements for victims of clergy sexual abuse.  We were told that this is what “Justice” required.  We were told that we, our immediate envelope dollars, would not pay for it but rather the reserves (savings, nest eggs) of each parish would.  We were told that this was for the abuses committed by clergy, coaches, and volunteers.  With all due respect:  Bullshit. 

If the clergy weren’t involved in this – to the staggering number over the decades – then the coaches and volunteers who were abusers would be left to their own resources to consider how to give “Justice” to victims.  I remember QUITE clearly how a youth ministry colleague came home from a Diocesan meeting of Directors of Religious Education & Youth Ministers at the very outset of this debacle back in the 1990’s.  She quoted Sister as saying, “If you, as a lay minister in the Church, have an allegation posed against you – even if it is false – you will NEVER do ministry in this Diocese again.”  Just the thought that the statement of a sophomore in high school who didn’t like the grade he/she got, or didn’t like me presenting the teaching of the Church on any topic could, with one FALSE accusation, destroy my ministry, my career, my reputation, my relationships with people who would not give the benefit of the doubt, made me absolutely ILL.  And yet it lodged in my mind that False Accusations are possible … and somehow that prepared me for the next thing to come… when someone I respected was falsely accused.  It also made me understand intuitively that the Church itself would NOT stand with its lay ministers (non-ordained, non-clergy) even if they are innocently accused.  How very Petrine. 

                    Peter was outside the courtyard as the trial of Jesus, the Innocent One, was going on.  “A                        servant girl came over and said, ‘You were one of those with Jesus the Galilean.’  But Peter                     denied it in front of everyone, ‘I don’t know what you’re talking about.’  (The third time he                     was asked he replied) ‘I don’t know the man!”                                                                    

                                                                                                         (Matthew 26:69, 74)

I am going to tell you how my brain is processing this whole thing.  You may agree.  You may disagree.  Agreement is not my concern.  I have to process it from the parameters of my own faith journey, my own life experience, my own knowledge of good and evil as I have seen it.  But I do hope it makes you think.  And frankly, my intent is not to tear-down, but to throw the spotlight so that more Truth is evident, more dots are connected.  I want to strongly encourage you (and to remind myself) of two things:  Let us not throw the baby (our deeply personal faith + our relationship with the Lord and HIS faith community that is very essential to us) with the bathwater (our frustrations of how this has and has not been handled or managed over the years) AND that there are some VERY GOOD, VERY HOLY priests and pastors out there who are suffering from the fallout around them.  I am sure they pray every day to not become victims of false witnesses.

For those who are guilty, I have very few words:  May you be locked in a gymnasium full of angry Catholic parents.  You would rather that the court throws you into Alcatraz, you’d fare better.  If someone touched MY children and did such things to them, my family better take out a tape measure and start custom fitting me for my own orange jumpsuit.  Just sayin’.

So, I want to air-out a few things.  First, I want to talk about the Allegations themselves.  Then I want to talk briefly about the nature of institutionalism.  Then, I will ramble about the pay-outs, oops, I mean renderings of justice.  Lastly, I will talk about the good clergy.  I do not know how long I will write for, perhaps until I am out of steam.  We will see how it goes.

####################

Sunday, June 11, 2023

"The Dog Ate My Homework" and other great excuses

 I was born around 5:35 p.m.  My mother missed supper that day because of me.  And I have been late to just about everything in my life by five minutes, no matter how hard I try.  I plan.  I calculate.  I set two alarms.   And, I am STILL 5 minutes late.

So I thought I would share some of the real life things that make me late... for entertainment purposes only...  

>I was walking my dog Timbyr one bright sunny morning before leaving for work.  I happened to notice in the tall grasses an incredible spider web.  It caught dew drops on it and they sparkled in the sunlight like diamonds.  I had to run inside to grab by camera so I could take a picture of it.

>I left the house a few minutes early, willing with all my might to be on time today.  I took the west-bound route to work and was reveling in the feeling that I was going to sit at my desk 5 minutes early with a victorious smile on my face.  I rounded the bend in the road and the police had blocked the entire road off due to a traffic accident just beyond them.  Not only was I not on time, I was later than I usually am late.

>Every morning when I let my three dogs out, there is a usual routine.  Valor and Sophia sleep in crates in my living room.  Madeline free ranges the house.  I open Sophia's crate.  I open Valor's crate.  He runs into Sophia's crate and grabs a chew toy or her favorite ball and taunts her to the doorway.  Meanwhile I am hopping on one leg because, well, "I gotta go" too!  I let them out.  Madeline parks her behind on the kitchen floor and refuses to go out.  Valor and Sophia get let back in, then Queen Madeline will go out.  I have a crook in my neck from looking over my shoulder to see if the youngest cat is lurking nearby to make a dash for it.  I do my entire morning routine, and then re-crate Valor & Sophia for the day so I can go to work.  I get in the car and start it.  I realize - dang - the dog toys need to go back into Sophia's crate so she won't be bored and crazy during the day.  I get out of the car.  I grab toys from the dog yard and bring them in to her.  I notice blotches on my floor, I look at the bottom of my shoe.  I think you know where THIS is going... I just want to say if I got them tee shirts, they would read:  "No one is in cahoots alone."

>I got in my vehicle a bit early trying to get my tardy self into shape... you've heard this before.  This time I took the east-bound route to work and got stuck behind a construction truck that was pulling forward in a way that I can only describe as "constipated" with similar sound effects.  He turned off on a side street; I moved my vehicle forward to find out what was slowing the construction truck down (more):  School buses.  Awk.

>I got into my vehicle and backed out of the garage.  I clicked the remote on the garage door.  Nothing.  I clicked it again.  Nothing.  I unbuckled my seatbelt, stuck my arm into the garage and hit the button on the wall.  I returned to my vehicle and started the process again.  Apparently when the temperature outside is less than 50 degrees, the remote is rather sluggish.  I wonder if I threw it out the window of a speeding vehicle how many pieces it would crack into when it hit the ground at 60 miles an hour.  Just sayin'.  

>I got into work and it was 8:28 a.m.  I was actually early - two minutes only, but I'm grateful.  Then I couldn't get my desktop to "wake-up" and let me log in.  I logged in at 8:34 am with a well-placed profanity and I walked over to our Everything Guy in the office to have him do something to my desktop computer.  I suggested blowing it up.  He chuckled.

>I got in to work and logged in at 8:34 a.m.  I was mad that I missed the mark again.  Then a thought came to me, "Refresh your screen."  I refreshed my screen and the computer logged me in as 8:45 a.m.  I marched myself over to our H.R. lady and asked her in my desperate, stressed-out voice to please look at her computer and note that it is not even 8:45 a.m. YET and my p.c. logged me in at 8:45.  How can this BE?!?  She had to call the software company and found out that if I am late beyond a certain time it automatically rolled me to the next 15 minute increment.  I did not know whether to cry or throw up.  It turns out that after reviewing ALL of the people who log in, only my log in was set up to do that.  I wanted to file for harassment, but the paperwork would probably be past the deadline.

>I left the house twenty minutes early because I wanted a coffee from you-know-where: Pink & Orange, America Runs On It ... And I got in line behind no less than NINE vehicles.  That particular store has a hard time moving the drive-thru traffic at a decent pace.  It is SO frustrating.  How early do I have to leave to not get stuck in the line?  Just asking for a friend....

I was not always late.  I am not late about ALL things.  My first term paper in college was ready THREE MONTHS EARLY because I was so nervous about doing well in college.  My peers laughed at me.  I got an A.  Laugh away, my friends.  

I am on-time for baby deliveries.  When a young mother calls and says, "I'm going to the hospital now," I can make it there within 30 minutes because my bag has been packed for at least six months beforehand.  

I am late for church and have become a "back-rower" as a result.  I don't mind it.  And if I know the music is going to be something other than engaging, I do not miss not participating in the Entrance Hymn.  Anyways, no one plays an Entrance Hymn for me.  Let's just say it is not necessarily an evangelism tool when no one really cares if you show up or not.  But that's a whole other topic.

How are my friendships impacted by me being late?  The people who can't handle it go away mad.  The people who forget that they have flaws, hound me about it, as if their nagging could change something that I have tried to change my whole entire life.  The people who forgive me everything show me a kindness I cannot muster up from within myself.  I do appreciate that.  It gives me a few special minutes to not feel guilty and crappy.  The people who are more-late than me (You know who you are!) make me feel better ... and it gives me someone to tease.

I can hardly wait to retire so that I can stop fighting this uphill battle.  But that is at least five years down the road, perhaps more.  So I keep on keeping on.  Does anyone have the time?  


One more for the road:

>As I scurried around the house getting one dog ready to go her veterinary appointment, I thought I should let all three out for one more potty break.  I have a fenced in side yard.  It is connected to a kinda fenced in back area ... and by "kinda" I mean:  I have wire-reinforced green snow fence that forms a long area for the dogs to run.  Snow fence, is primarily to prevent snow drifting but in this case, it was an economical solution to the need for a bigger area for the dogs to run.... except that it flexes a bit if you put pressure on it.  I let the dogs run, and Valor spotted the ducks hanging around the pond at the back of the yard.  He immediately went to the fence, leaned on it and with all his youthful enthusiasm, scaled right over it and went to the ducks.  He circled the green algae-laden pond and the duck taunted him from the center.  She glided in circles, her white feathering a stark contrast to the green sea of algae on which she paddled.  He couldn't stand it anymore:  he romped into the pond.  Already at this point, I had Madeline in her crate in the car to go to the vet's office.  I returned Sophia into the house for safe keeping.  I ran out to the back yard to call  him in, but no-dice, he wasn't interested.  He had found his true sport:  water + ducks and was not ready to stop.  Earlier that week, I had put nice pink seat covers on the inside of my vehicle.  I knew I had to make a sacrifice.  The only thing this dog loves hearing more than treats are the words:  "Let's go bye!"  I drove out to the backyard, parked the vehicle, lifted the tailgate and yelled, "Let's go bye!"  He came careening out of that duck pond (completely filthy and stinky), up into the tailgate, over the crate in the back seat, and onto the pink seat covers.  I made a big deal out of him coming to me... a good big deal ... because you always want to reward a dog for listening even if the thing that came before it was utterly naughty.  I drove him to the house, hauled him into his crate and left him there to stink until I could return from the vet appointment with Mad-Dog.  If I didn't love dogs so much, I wouldn't survive it. 🙏


  



Monday, May 22, 2023

A Homily that Could Give Kids Nightmares (Homiletics Review - #7 in a series)

 



Worst First Communion Homily ever.  That's the award I would give it.  I could not believe my ears.  I imagine there could be worse, but I will let  you be the judge.  Think and decide.  Think from the perspective of someone who has had to sit through at least 5 trainings on "Safe Environment:  Protecting the Youth."  Think from the perspective of someone who was raised on the phrases like, "that's not a very nice thing to say," and "we don't talk like that."  And let me begin at a previous homily to set the backdrop.

All during COVID there was this strange tension in our Catholic sensibilities.  We were always taught that on Sunday, if you weren't dead, you had better be in Church.  It was a mortal sin to miss it unless YOU were gravely ill.  This is how the first Christian Church lived out the commandment to honor the Sabbath day and keep it holy:  You show up, you pray, you have donuts.  (well, donuts were a more recent addition because someone decided that having a coffee after church "builds community."  A discussion for another series.)  So here comes a pandemic and our State leaders said, "Everyone stays home.  No work.  No School.  No Sports.  No Church."  Wow.  You just wiped-out American culture in one fell-swoop so it must be pretty serious.  But even the Bishops climbed on board and said, "You can attend Mass virtually on television to satisfy the obligation to attend Mass" during the height of the pandemic.  I give my utmost respect to the priests who thought outside of the proverbial box and did Parking Lot Liturgies and taped off every other row in church to attain to the Social Distancing.  What could be worse than to deprive Catholics the spiritual support we receive from holy communion during a period when we needed it most?  And now, because of this extreme measure, taken with good motives from the Bishops' perspective, we have lost at least 33% of church goers.  They just haven't come back.  Perhaps they figured out that you would not drop dead from skipping Mass.

I went to a great suburban parish during the re-integration time.  It was led by two priests and two deacons that were just super fantastic.  And that is high praise from me, the Most Critical of Critics.       I am critical not because I am mean, but because I believe in thinking outside of the box and so few people do it.  Frankly, it irks the hell out of me.  The only people who sing the Fiddler on the Roof song "Tradition, Tradition!" about rules louder than Rebbe Tevyye are Catholic leadership.  And that has cost us credibility and consequently members.  

So at the end of the pandemic, the unthinkable happens and my two hero-priests are re-assigned.  The new leadership comes in and I knew two things within 5 minutes of the first homily I heard him preach: 1) that I would have to give him wide berth because he had a certain demeanor; 2) that he was a canon lawyer.  It seems so odd to me that we have canon law when Jesus was pretty clear He came to install mercy and love as the new basis for decision-making.  While the Jews had 777 mini laws, the Canon Lawyers have hundreds more.  I get it, that we make rules to make sure everyone, every case, is treated fairly but my gosh, really.  And, YES, I HAVE READ CANON LAW.  

The first homily jarred me to the core.  He announced to the parish via his sermon that "no longer would lectors sit in the sanctuary area, because they are not the same character as priests and deacons.  They must sit in the benches and come forward from within the laity to read the Scriptures."  Here's this about that.  Most people sitting there have NO clue that the term "character" in that context is a liturgical term referring to members of the community having certain roles that are proper to them.  So the role of the Presider of Liturgy (aka: the priest or celebrant) is to sit nearby the altar.  The deacon, also consecrated to preach the gospel in a unique laity role gets to sit there too.  The laity (aka:  the "pray-pay-obey" group sits in the herd).  Most people don't know that "character" is related to the idea of liturgical roles.  What they interpret is:  "you aren't as holy as us, so you sit out there."  Not mentioning that this church has a wide sanctuary area where there is room for all, and for elderly lectors it cuts out the possibility of them falling as they go up the sanctuary steps when they get up to read.  Not mentioning that I used to attend a Teen Mass in another place where the youth were invited INTO the sanctuary area during the consecration to gather more literally around the altar, to be invited INTO the mystery as God's chosen ones.  Not mentioning that when Christ died on the cross, the Scriptures say that the veil in the sanctuary of the Jewish temple was torn miraculously from top to bottom - a sign that there is no separation between us and God:  He WANTS us closer and has made the way for us to be reconciled to Him in His Holiness.

Then the homilist took aim at the few Traditional Catholics who, in that parish, sat in the back row of the Church so that when they came up to receive communion they could exercise their preference of kneeling on one knee (genuflecting) in honor to the Lord prior to receiving holy communion.  He told them they could NO LONGER practice that way, suggesting that they could cause an older congregant to trip and break a  hip.  Yes, he really said that.  Are you KIDDING ME?!  He then thanked the people who received communion on the tongue for not biting his hand ... lately.  (Most people receive the communion bread in their hand and place it in their own mouth, which is a practice that came about in the late 1970's.  Prior to that EVERY Catholic received communion at a kneeler on BOTH knees, and the priest placed the host directly into their mouth when they said, "Amen."  I truly hope those Traditional Catholics were big money donors to the parish and took their wallets with them to go to the Church down the street that will respect their preference without insulting them in front of the whole congregation.

What we have here is someone who picks and chooses which people he is okay with tripping and falling and breaking hips.  He is a man who appears okay with just insulting a percentage of the congregation that at least COMES to Mass with a level of devotion and piety that is admirable.  His words betray a level of clericalism and iconoclasm that is ironic.  I said to myself, "I love the music here.  The people are kind.  It is a great church.  But if I drop anchor here there will be fireworks eventually."  So I left.  Remember that cigarette commercial that said, "It's better to fight than switch"?  In this case, it isn't.  I can go to St. Whomever's parish without the caustic sermons.

Which brings me to yesterday morning, where I ended up going to that church to give it another try.  What I mean by "another try" is that I hoped my Catholic sensibilities would not be offended.  Strike two.  

The church was packed because it was First Communion Sunday for the children.  A mother with an infant and two little children ages about 5 and 8 sat next to me.  Mysteriously, she took her baby and left me with her kids.  I thought she just took the baby out to the bathroom.  Perhaps she was standing in the back somewhere.  But there I was with her two children, one of whom was clearly "unchurched" and kept talking and fidgeting.  At one point I gave her the "shush" finger to my lips and whispered, "we  have to be quiet we are praying now."  At another point, I pulled the kneeler down so we could kneel and she asked quite loudly what that was for.  I explained, "we are praying this way now."  Then I asked the older of the two, "Have you made your First Communion?" (no.)  "Okay.  So you see how the girls are dressed up like little brides and the boys like little grooms?  That is because they love Jesus and are asking Him to come into their heart in a special way today.  The priest will give them a little piece of bread which is called the Body of Jesus."  It was very basic catechesis.  I actually encouraged the little one to stand on the kneeler when the First communion kids went up to the front of the church so she could see them.  It is always a great sight to see, the finer moment of Catholic childhood.

But before that vignette was the homily.  Now I ask you, if you see someone come out into a group of people with a baseball bat in his right hand, tapping the top middle of it with his flat left hand, would it make you nervous?  And then if he was to step towards beautiful children and fake like he was going to hit them with it, does it sit wrong with you?  Then put that someone in a priest's vestments and picture starting a homily that way.  It is INAPPROPRIATE.  It is offensive to anyone's sensibilities.  And if we laugh it is because it is AWKWARD LAUGHTER.  Because ... in your right mind ... when you see little kids who are 7-8 years old dressed like little brides and little grooms because they love Jesus, what about that picture makes you think of even JOKING with a baseball bat?

He anchored his homily in a story involving two kids running crying to their mother.  One said, "He hit me with a baseball bat."  The mother said, "And what did YOU hit him with?"  The kid replied, "Everything else."  The congregation chuckled.  The story was cute.  But it didn't seem right to apply that to this situation.  If a lay person said that to kids in a religious education class, that person would be banned from interaction with kids.  Decades ago, before there were workshops about child safety and appropriate adult behavior, I as a program leader had to lecture an adult male teacher who shoved a surly 7th grade boy up against a wall.  He used his size and force as an intimidation factor to get the kid to behave.  If he did that nowadays, he'd need a defense lawyer, and rightly so.  

There we were in this church, celebrating this special day for the children with a priest teasing that he was going to hit someone with a baseball bat.  I think it's time for a sabbatical for someone, just saying.  So what about the rest of the homily?  Indeed.  What about it?  No explanation for how special this day is for Catholics.  No referencing the Scriptures on the beautiful practice of receiving communion.  Visiting unchurched adults were there a-plenty, and no invitation for them to explore the beliefs of Catholicism or consider reactivating their own faith practices to cope with the stressors of modern life.  No call to consider the wonder of the gift of Christ for our salvation.  No explanation of how Jesus can come into your heart and give your life beauty and purpose and stability.  No nothing.  A huge missed opportunity.  Maybe it was more important to him that he be perceived as "one of the guys," but I for one lost all respect... and so I sadly give the award of:  Worst Homily Ever.

For those of you who are reading this series for tips on how to craft a good homily, here they are:  Never miss an opportunity to talk about the Mercy and Graciousness of God.  Never hold back from talking about the things in Catholic life that are beautiful, symbolic, and meaningful on so many levels.  Never hesitate to incorporate an appropriate story that may help broaden the understanding of people... stories captivate us.  And Never, Ever, Ever joke about physical violence in a church where there are innocent children sitting there, perhaps adult survivors of violence present, or others who are sick and tired of attending the damned Virtus Trainings when there are clergy who feel exempt from living the Safe Environment credo.  Oh, yeah, and maybe throw in a Scripture quote.  Lord, deliver us...

###############

I know there are those who will consider this bad form for airing dirty laundry.  Thank you for your concern.  Be advised:  I am done with propriety and silence when the nonsense continues.  If I knew the Bishop, I would call him.

***************

Important update as of 06/13/23.  This homilist has been transferred to another parish from where he spent less than a year as pastor.  I guess Someone VOTED with their envelope dollars or called the Bishop.

*****************